Best XO Cognacs for 2016: A Top 10 Family Tasting

It might surprise you to know that some of our favorite cognac-brands?utm_source=blog&utm_medium=artikel&utm_campaign=kblinker” title=”More about cognac brands »”>Cognac brands include those of some of the smaller, artisan houses. Of course, we also love the ‘big boys’ as well, but when it comes to finding some of the best Cognac brands (visit our top list) there are, it always pays to discover the craft producers.

And this left us with only one thing to do; a family tasting session to discover which were really our favorites. Yes, we know, it’s a tough job – but someone’s gotta do it!

Just to let you know: This list has been created from our own independent tasting session.  We’ve not received any fees from Cognac brands or producers – it’s our personal ‘Top 10’.

We did an extensive tasting with XO Cognac »”>XO Cognacs, in the French countryside.  After all, it’s been said that the location in which you taste something has its own bearing on your enjoyment.  So where else to choose to taste Cognac – but in Cognac?

The tasting team consisted of myself, Max, and 3 family members.  Our goal was to identify the best 10 XO Cognacs from our cabinet for 2016.  We tasted 24 different XOs, and only the 10 best made it onto the list.  And what an eclectic selection – from Martell Cordon Bleu to Drouet.  So enjoy (we did!).

It’s been a while since we posted our last XO Cognac Top 10 list – that was back in 2011.  That particular list was based on popularity data.

This time, however, our top 10 list has been created on taste alone.  It was a completely blind taste test.  We didn’t know the brand, and we didn’t see any packaging or bottles.

The best XO Cognacs for 2016

Let’s first explain how we came up with our favorites.  We rated our tasting results using a point system based on the valuation averages of each member of the tasting team. These notes were structured, combining tasting aromas that were split into four general taste categories: Flower, Fruit, Wood, and Spice.  The ‘Smooth’ value is based on a 1-10 star rating.

You can see how each Cognac scored in each category on the individual diagrams below each one.  This identifies the tendencies of each Cognac – be they leaning towards spicy, woody, fruity etc.  And you’ll also see the ‘smooth’ rating represented as well.

So – that’s enough of the talking.  Let’s get on with the results.  Drum roll please…

 

1st Place – 96 points: Otard »”>Baron Otard XO

 

A somewhat surprising winner…  We first tasted this Cognac a few years ago during our Chateau de Cognac & Otard visit.  We also took home a bottle – a bottle that somehow did not get as much attention in our cabinet as it should have.  Baron Otard XO Gold is an extra old blend of Grande Champagne, Borderies, and Fins Bois eaux-de-vie.

Buy & Info

 

Baron Otard XO was a worthy winner, receiving a massive 96 points rating by our tasting team.

 

2nd place – 94 points: XO Francois Voyer Cognac Gold

We tasted Voyer Gold XO for the first time in 2010.  And in our independent taste test this is a worthy second place winner.  ‘Gold’ is a pure Grande Champagne Cognac, a rich authentic delight from artisanal Cognac producer, Francois Voyer.

Buy & Info

Voyer’s Gold XO offers excellent value for money and has received many awards. Discover Voyer Gold Cognac.

 

3rd place – 93 points: Braastad XO Fine Champagne

This braastad cognac »”>Braastad Cognac was not a regular component of our cabinet until recently. It was only during last summer that our neighbor introduced us to this XO, and we thought it was really well balanced, complex, and rich. The blend consists of grapes from the Grande Champagne and Petite Champagne region of Cognac.

Buy & Info

Discover Braastad XO Fine Champagne.

 

4th place – 91 points: Cordon Bleu Martell Cognac

Martell Cordon Bleu is an absolute classic.  A very spicy, masculine XO Cognac – in a beautiful bottle. In our opinion the best Martell bottle and one of the best XOs out there.

Buy & Info

The Borderies eaux-de-vie in this Martell blend make the Cognac somewhat exotic: pepper-ish and complex. Discover Cordon Bleu.

 

5th place – 90 points: De Luze XO Cognac

We’ve always liked this XO by De Luze. A Cognac that’s about 20 years old, and a typically mature Fine Champagne Cognac. This blend of Grande Champagne and Petite Champagne makes up a great Cognac with dark fruit and spices, and delicious first hints of rancio.

Buy & Info

And by the way, the bottle is really great too. An excellent all-round product that offers really good value for money. Discover De Luze XO.

 

6th place – 87 points: Hennessy XO Cognac

Hennessy XO »”>Hennessy XO is, many would say, one of the best Cognacs out there. Hennessy has a long tradition of dominating the race for the highest quality sources of eaux-de-vie.  And the contracts it holds with top winegrowers and distillers guarantees first-class Cognac making. This Cognac is very round, no sharpness, and the spices are not too heavy. All in all, a very complete and balanced XO.

Buy & Info

Hennessy XO Cognac Extra Old comes in an iconic bottle: Both the shape and quality of the decanter are exceptional.
Discover Hennessy XO.

 

7th place – 84 points: ABK6 XO Family Reserve Aged 10 Years

ABK6 XO Family Reserve is a Single Estate Extra Old Cognac from the Cognac producer, Domaines Abecassis, some 10 minutes away from our house in the region.  This Family Reserve was aged for more than 10 years in oak barrels.

Buy & Info

Discover ABK6 XO Family ReserveABK6 XO Family Reserve.

 

8th place – 83 points: Louis Royer XO

A complex Cognac: masculine and rich.  Royer‘s XO is one of these very deeply mature Cognacs, with great hints of dark fruits – full of aromas with a long finish.

Buy & Info

Read more and purchase Louis Royer XO CognacLouis Royer XO Cognac.

 

9th place – 81 points: Leopold Gourmel Age du Fruit 10 Carats

The Léopold Gourmel XO Age du Fruit 10 Carat Cognac is an old XO Fin Bois Cognac. At 41 % ABV, it matches well after white wines, after white meat or fish – or even complements Asian cuisine.  The Age Du Fruit is produed without additives, aged in un-toasted French oak casks, is never chill filtered – and there are certainly no artifial wood notes or the addition of caramel.

Buy & Info

Discover Leopold Gourmel Age du Fruit Cognac.

 

10th place – 80 points: Drouet & Fils XO Ulysse Grande Champagne

Drouet XO Cognac is a bottle that somehow slipped into the tasting, we hadn’t planned to include it. But we’re glad we did… This Grande Champagne Cognac gives a round, deep-bodied experience – the team liked it.

Buy & Info

Discover Drouet & Fils XO Ulysee.

 

We tasted 24 XOs in total. There were 4 members of the panel, including me – Max. The scoring was solely on the nose, body, and after taste. We hope you like our tasting results and find them useful.

Please feel free to comment below. Any feedback or thoughts are appreciated.

For Cognac producers: Make sure to be part of the next tasting: We’re preparing a VSOP tasting this summer. Write to tastingaward@cognac-expert.com to make sure to be included for free. 

Comments (16)

  1. Bruce April 2, 2016 at 11:28 am

    Great work team of Cognac Expert! I can’t wait to taste the Drouet XO which I ordered from your website on friday. I understand you’ll be doing another tasting this year?

  2. Max (Cognac-Expert.com) April 2, 2016 at 6:29 pm

    Hi Bruce, thanks and I’m happy you like our selection. I can tell you this was some (fund) work! Really happy to hear that you picked the Drouet XO. Drouet is an authentic family producer who just remade their bottle design. Yes, we’re going to do another tasting in 2016, probably a VSOP tasting.

  3. audoin de Dampierre April 6, 2016 at 9:42 am

    Great what you have done here. It would be great to include Chateau de Plassac for the next tasting.
    —-
    Superbe ce que vous avez fait
    Serait il possible d’inclure le Château de Plassac, ainsi que vous l’avez gentiment proposé, une prochaine fois pour une prochaine dégustation.
    Cordialement à vous
    A de Dampierre

  4. Ole April 6, 2016 at 4:19 pm

    This is sad.
    Your list corresponds with the most sugared cognacs.
    There are only 2 cognacs on this list I would buy; those not hiding the eau-de-vie with added caramel and sugar.
    Ole in Oslo

  5. Johan Claeson April 6, 2016 at 7:30 pm

    Thank You for this report. Highly interesting facts but You have forgotten Courvoisier XO and Bache Gabrielsen XO. Superbe Cognas both of them!
    Sincerely
    Johan Claeson

  6. Max (Cognac-Expert.com) April 7, 2016 at 10:12 am

    Dear Audoin, it’s true we did not include your XO in this tasting because it was simply no longer there in our cabinet. Everyone: Chateau de Plassac XO is a nice hidden champion.

    Dear Ole, which Cognacs would you buy from this list? Which one would you say has the most sugar & caramel?

    Dear Johan, we did not include Courvoisier XO nor Bache Gabrielsen XO – we may do that for the next tasting.

  7. Kevin Baker April 7, 2016 at 11:44 am

    Hi,
    Did you taste any of the Gautier cognacs?
    The XO Gold & Blue won ‘World’s Best Cognac’ at the World Cognac Awards last year, while the Tradition Rare and Pinar Del Rio got ‘Best Cognac’ in the San Francisco Spirits competition in 2015 and 2016, respectively.

  8. Magnus Sørensen April 9, 2016 at 12:31 am

    You obviously offer a decent online shop but your tasting is way off . 96 pts for the Baron Otard XO and 87 pts for Hennessy XO ? ? Stick to your blogs which I very much enjoy but no so much your very limited ratings list which has no structure, maybe and please provide a list of criterion used for the ratings .

    Magnus from Tromsø

  9. Max (Cognac-Expert.com) April 11, 2016 at 10:52 am

    Dear Kevin, yes I personally know the Gautier range – it didn’t make it in the top 10 here.

    Dear Magnus, to be very honest with you I was also surprised to see the end result. I personally really like the Baron Otard VSOP for instance, and obviously the Hennessy XO is a very, very good blend. But, I can tell you that strange things happened when you do blind tastings. The result is an average out of 4 different tasting results. What kind of information would you need in terms of rating? We’re open for any suggestion here.

  10. Ryan June 1, 2016 at 12:23 pm

    No Tesseron? Very surprised it did not make your list.

  11. Marc July 26, 2016 at 11:06 pm

    Tesseron would be a good choice here on the list. Their cognacs are extremly smooth and light, which makes them really special and great for certain drinkers.

  12. Sharon September 21, 2016 at 4:09 pm

    My husband has just started drinking cognac and I want to get him a nice (and affordable) bottle for his birthday. I can’t seem to find the “Baron Otard XO Gold Extra Old Cognac” in Australia. Would the “Hennessy XO” be a good choice? He likes smoothness and the spice to be mild in his drinks.

  13. Chris October 6, 2016 at 1:22 pm

    Great job! Coincides 99% with my past experiences. One question. Could you do an XO or even Hors d’Age testing that is confined to family owned independent producers in the future? Like many tourists (in my case a house in the Perigord) I pass through the region once or twice a year. Whereas I can easily get the big brands anywhere in the world I find it quite hard to distinguish the merely ok from the excellent among the Small Independent producers unique to the area and at 70-150 € a bottle (and as a driver!) You do not want to make mistakes

  14. Max (Cognac-Expert.com) October 20, 2016 at 12:08 pm

    That’s a great idea, we shall get onto that!

  15. Max (Cognac-Expert.com) October 20, 2016 at 12:13 pm

    Hennessy XO is a good XO to start of with, yes. Please note that you can also find the Cognacs in our online shop here at Cognac-Expert.com.

  16. Joe Murf December 20, 2016 at 3:41 am

    Kirkland Cognac XO
    Sold at Costco

    Origin?
    Source?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

[i]
[i]